Your first performance process: where to start

Written by

in

Performance

"Our team keeps asking how they are doing. Where do we start with reviews?"

Growing companies often reach this moment between 15 and 50 people. Your team wants 3 things:

  • To know what great work looks like in their role
  • To hear how they are doing, regularly
  • To see a path to grow with you

Performance management gives them all 3. It starts simple: clear expectations, a regular rhythm, and managers who know what to say.

What the research says

  • Gallup found that only 14% of employees strongly agree their performance reviews inspire them to improve.
  • Only 2 in 10 feel their performance is managed in a way that motivates them.
  • What motivates people is simple, regular and honest feedback.

What I have seen

In 15 years in tech consulting, I have designed how teams develop, coach and promote their people.

On a team of 40+ consultants, I coached managers through development plans, improvement plans and promotion decisions. The results:

  • Every manager followed the same clear steps to develop their people
  • 87% of the team was promoted from within
  • The company kept its talent and saved on hiring

For a growing technology company, I built performance management into the full people function, on tools the team already used. The team started right away, using what they already had.

5 steps to your first performance process

1. Write down what great looks like

  • What to do: for each role, write 3 to 5 clear expectations people can check themselves against.
  • Example: "A senior consultant leads client meetings, delivers on time, and coaches 1 junior colleague."
  • Why it works: people meet expectations they can see. This step answers most of their questions.

2. Set a simple rhythm

  • What to do: a monthly 1 on 1 for every person, and a short review every 6 months.
  • Example: "First Tuesday of the month, 30 minutes. In April and October, a 1 page written review."
  • Why it works: regular feedback feels normal and useful. People adjust as they go.

3. Give managers the same 3 questions

  • What to do: ask every manager to use the same questions in every review.
  • Example: "What went well? What would make the next 6 months better? What support do you need from me?"
  • Why it works: reviews are fair across teams, and new managers have a clear place to start.

4. Prepare managers for the hard conversation

  • What to do: before the first cycle, run a short session on how to tell someone they are below expectations, and what happens next.
  • Example: "Here is what I expected. Here is what I saw. Here is what needs to change by next month, and here is how I will support you."
  • Why it works: the hardest conversation is often the most important one. Practice makes it clear and kind.

5. Start with the tools you already have

  • What to do: use a shared document or the platform your team already works in. Add software later, when you need it.
  • Example: "1 template per role in the shared drive, and a calendar reminder for every 1 on 1."
  • Why it works: people adopt what is simple. The habit comes first, the tools follow.

Already running reviews? Read How your team can know where they stand before review day.

Your takeaway for this week

  • Pick 1 role on your team.
  • Write the 3 expectations that define great work in that role.
  • Share them with the person in that role and ask: "Is this how you see your job too?"

Ready to build it?

I advise growing tech companies on their people processes, including performance management, as a fractional people leader or on a defined project. I also design and facilitate workshops for managers on the performance conversations that matter most.

Let us talk: samiradiallo.com/people-strategy

Sources: Gallup, "Why your performance management is broken.

Samira Diallo

About the author

Samira Diallo

Samira Diallo is a bilingual (French and English) people strategy advisor, facilitator and speaker based in Toronto. She spent 15+ years in global tech consulting at Capgemini and Oracle, leading technology projects and the people side of the teams delivering them. Today, she helps companies keep their best people and coaches professionals building the career that works for them.

← All insights

Free guide

Start an employee resource group

Want people to feel they belong at your company? 5 steps to start an employee resource group.

Get the free checklist